Obesity and C-Section StatLit Materials

Obesity and C-Section StatLit Materials

Some stuff from Thursday’s class. Here’s the facilitator’s notes as well, if you want to run this in your own class.

It’s a sort of “case-study lite” approach. I gave the students the following in a packet: 

  • An article talking about research which showed people born by C-section are at a 50% greater risk of obesity than those that weren’t, and speculating C-sections may be behind the obesity epidemic
  • An abstract of that research study
  • A chart showing growth of C-sections since 1970
  • An article talking about why C-sections have increased since 1970 (It’s not for the reasons you think). 
  • A chart showing the growth of obesity over since 1970
Their role was described as follows:

For this scenario, you will play the role of an obesity researcher who has been asked by a hospital to see if there are extraneous variables in this study that were not accounted for. The hospital is trying to decide whether they should include the following sentence in their materials on C-section:

“Choosing to deliver your child by C-section may increase your child’s risk of future obesity.”

The instructions were: 
  • Produce a brief predictor-outcome statement. What is predicting what? How is it measured? What is the magnitude and direction of the association? 
  • Using the charts, produce a statement on whether the U.S. gains in childhood obesity roughly mirror the growth in C-sections.  
  • Produce a statement on whether the base rate of C-sections is large enough to have the suggested impact on obesity. 
  • Produce a list of all potential lurking variables controlled for. 
  • Produce a list of some lurking variables not controlled for. 
  • Give your gut-level take on whether any of the potential lurking variables not controlled for might dramatically reduce the magnitude of the association, or potentially reverse it. If you believe one of the lurking variables could do that, name it, and explain why it might account for the apparent association.

As with many simulations, we’ve loaded the dice a bit here. The news articles we used had reference to some confounders, but we removed those references. There is a very obvious lurking variable, one which was later controlled for in a subsequent study which found no effect of C-section on obesity.

The background information on the growth of C-sections holds the key to understanding what’s going on. In that article, it explains much of the growth of C-sections is due to overweight mothers — expecting mothers who are overweight often have to have C-sections due to obesity or obesity related illness. 

That’s a classic lurking variable scenario. Overweight mothers will be over-represented in the C-section group due to medical reasons. Due to genetics, overweight mothers will also have overweight children at a higher rate than mothers not overweight. So it is completely expected that the C-section group would have a larger percentage of children who grow up to be obese.

The one mistake I made running this was to run it too slow, and without stages. I would suggest you budget at LEAST 45 minutes for this activity, and rather than have the student groups report out all the questions at the end, have them report out the answers to the first half of the questions, then give them some more time to put together answers for the second half.

I ran this in a much more compressed time frame, and one of my eight groups got it, and another very nearly got it — which wasn’t bad. But ideally you’d have at least half the groups get in the vicinity of the answer (or produce other, equally compelling answers). 

If you try it, tell me how it goes.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Obesity and C-Section StatLit Materials

  1. Admiring the time and effort you put into your site and detailed information you present.
    It’s awesome to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same outdated rehashed information.
    Fantastic read! I’ve bookmarked your site and I’m adding your RSS feeds to my Google account.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s